We’ve Moved! Visit our new location at 2/344 Keilor Road, Niddrie.

Book an Appointment

Finding your way around oral health, restoring your beautiful smile and regaining dental functionality can be difficult. However, two of the most common treatment options are traditional dentures and dental implants. These dental procedures have revolutionised the field of dentistry, giving hope and confidence to those suffering from tooth loss. This decision impacts your facial appearance, overall oral health, and lifestyle. But which one is right for you?

In this article, we aim to shed light on this important topic. We will explore the world of dental implants vs dentures, discussing the benefits and drawbacks of each. We’ll also touch on the crucial aspect of dental implant maintenance, which is often overlooked but is key for the longevity of your dental treatment.

Whether you’re a candidate for dental implants seeking long-term reliability or exploring dentures as a more budget-friendly alternative, our goal is to provide a comprehensive, well-researched guide to equip you with the knowledge necessary to have a productive conversation with your dentist and to help you make an informed decision about your dental health. Let’s dive into the world of dental restoration and explore which option suits you best.

Dental @ Niddrie Plaza

Summary of the Content:

  • Dental implants and dentures are good alternative options for tooth replacement, each with pros and cons.

  • Dental implants offer a natural feel, look, and longevity and help maintain bone health.

  • Dentures are a more affordable option. They are non-invasive, and require less chair time because it is quicker to fit.

  • The choice between the two depends on personal circumstances, oral health, lifestyle, and preferences.

  • Dental implants can be treated as natural teeth, which requires regular brushing, flossing, and dental check-ups,

  • Dentures maintenance is more meticulous. They require frequent cleaning, and you need to remove and soak it overnight.

  • Both options can impact lifestyle, affecting everything from eating, speaking and self-confidence.

Understanding Dental Implants and Dentures

Dentures and dental implants are popular choices to effectively replace missing teeth, each with its unique benefits and purpose.

Dental implants are a cutting-edge dental restoration procedure that is more than just replacing the visible tooth portion. These titanium implants are biocompatible and are screwed into the jawbone. They fuse with the bone through a process known as osseointegration. Atop the implant screw, a dental crown is meticulously crafted to replicate the look and feel of a natural tooth. The remarkable strength, durability and stability of dental implants make them a compelling choice for individuals seeking a more cost-effective option for long-term replacement.

Conversely, dentures are removable and versatile dental appliances designed to replace missing teeth and surrounding tissues. They come in two main types: complete dentures for those with no remaining natural teeth and partial dentures for individuals with some natural teeth still intact. Dentures are custom-made to snugly fit the mouth of the patient, offering the convenience of being easily removable and reinserted as needed, especially during cleaning.

Both dental implants and removable dentures replace missing teeth, enhance oral function, and improve the aesthetics of one’s smile. However, the decision between the two often depends on several factors, including the patient’s lifestyle, oral health, and budget. It is recommended to carefully weigh the benefits of dental implants vs dentures and the drawbacks that come with them before making a choice. Your dentist can provide invaluable guidance in making the right decision to suit your specific needs.

The Procedure: Dental Implants vs Dentures

The procedures for getting dental implants and conventional dentures differ significantly, each with its steps and timeframes.

Dental Implant Procedure:

  1. Consultation and Planning:
    This involves a thorough dental examination and a review of your medical history review. This step allows us to create a personalised treatment plan tailored to your needs.

  2. Tooth Extraction (If needed):
    If a damaged tooth is still in place, it will be comfortably extracted to make room for the dental implant.

  3. Bone Grafting (if necessary):
    A dental bone grafting procedure may be recommended if the jawbone lacks adequate thickness or density to support the implant.

  4. Implant Placement:
    The surgical placement of the biocompatible material titanium post is the key stage of the dental implant procedure. This screw serves as the anchor or the tooth root of your new tooth or crown.

  5. Healing and Growth:
    During the healing phase, the implant bonds with your natural bone through osseointegration, ensuring stability and strength.

  6. Abutment Placement:
    Once the healing period is complete, an abutment is attached to the implant, which acts as the connector between the implant and the final restoration.

  7. Crown Placement:
    The final step of the dental implant procedure involves the fabrication of a custom-designed dental crown to match the shade and shape of your natural teeth. This is securely affixed to the abutment to restore aesthetics and functionality.



Denture Fabrication Procedure:

  1. Consultation and Customised Planning:
    The denture process involves a comprehensive dental exam, where your medical history is reviewed to customise a treatment plan to meet your needs and expectations.

  2. Impressions and Measurements:
    Impressions of your mouth are taken to create a detailed model of your mouth, which serves as the basis for crafting custom-made dentures. Jaw and bite measurements are also taken during this stage.

  3. Denture Design and Fabrication:
    The dental laboratory or your dentist will fabricate your custom dentures using acrylic resin. They will ensure that they fit comfortably and function naturally in your mouth.

  4. Denture Fitting:
    The dentures are then fitted, and adjustments are made to make sure they fit snugly and comfortably. This is a crucial step to ensure that they feel natural and do not cause discomfort or pain.

  5. Home Care and Follow-up Appointments:
    You are given at-home care instructions to maintain your dentures during the adjustment period. Additionally, regular check-ups are needed to evaluate your oral health, monitor the fit and condition of your dentures, and make occasional adjustments over time.


Both dental implant and denture procedures involve a consultation and planning phase, where personalised treatment plans are created based on dental exams and medical history reviews. Both procedures are ideal options to restore dental functionality and aesthetics and offer long term benefits for your smile.

However, there is a significant difference between dentures and dental implants. Dental implants involve the surgical placement of a titanium post into the jawbone to provide a strong foundation for the replacement tooth. And dentures are custom-made prosthetic devices that sit on the gums.

Pros and Cons of Dental Implants

Dental implants have gained popularity due to their durability and natural feel. They can be a suitable option over dentures. However, they may not be the right choice for everyone. Let’s look at some of the benefits of dental implants and the drawbacks of dental implants.

Advantages of Dental Implants:

  1. Natural Appearance and Feel:
    Dental implants closely mimic natural teeth’ appearance and function, offering a comfortable fit and feel, and giving you a boost of confidence after tooth loss.

  2. Durability:
    Dental implants can last long with proper care.

  3. Bone Health:
    Dental implants stimulate bone growth, helping to prevent bone loss in the jaw.

  4. No Impact on Adjacent Teeth:
    Unlike dental bridges, dental implants don’t require altering the structure of the neighbouring teeth.



Drawbacks of Dental Implants:

  1. Cost:
    Dental implants are often more expensive than other tooth replacement options.

  2. Implant Surgery Required:
    Dental implants involve an invasive procedure and require sufficient bone density. Inadequate bone structure will require bone grafting to reduce the bone deterioration in the area where the implant will be placed.

  3. Longer Treatment Time:
    After getting dental implants, healing time can take several months.

  4. Not Suitable for Everyone:
    Certain conditions and diseases, such as diabetes and cancer, can affect the success of dental implants. Additionally, active periodontal disease will need to be managed first prior to implant placement.


While the benefits of dental implants are numerous, it’s important to learn about the drawbacks of dental implants and discuss these factors with your dentist to determine if they are the right choice for you.

Pros and Cons of Dentures

Dentures have been a common option for tooth loss for many years. There are several advantages of dentures but also come with their own set of drawbacks. Let’s explore these in more detail.

Pros of Dentures:

  1. Cost-Effective:
    Dentures are a more affordable tooth replacement treatment option than dental implants. Non-Invasive: Getting dentures does not require oral surgery, which can be a significant advantage for unsuitable surgical procedure candidates.

  2. Quick Treatment:
    Getting dentures is relatively quick, usually requiring a few weeks compared to several months for dental implants.

  3. Versatility:
    Traditional dentures can replace several missing teeth, even an entire arch of teeth, giving you a more confident.


Cons of Dentures:

  1. Comfort and Fit:
    Dentures may not fit as securely as dental implants, resulting in discomfort and difficulties with speech and eating.

  2. Proper Maintenance:
    Dentures require regular cleaning and must be removed at night.

  3. Longevity:
    Dentures generally need to be replaced every 5-7 years. The fit may not be the same as the possibility of bone resorption is only slowed down, not eliminated.

  4. Bone Loss:
    Unlike dental implants, dentures do not stimulate bone growth and can lead to a certain degree of bone loss over time.


Understanding these pros and cons of dental implants vs dentures can help you decide whether dentures are the right choice for your dental health needs.

Cost Comparison: Dental Implants vs Dentures

One of the key factors many people consider when choosing between dental implants vs dentures as the long-term treatment option is cost. Here’s a general comparison of the costs involved in both options:

Dental Implants

Dental implants are a more expensive treatment option, and they usually require a significant investment upfront. Single-tooth implant cost starts from $4,500. The initial cost can vary significantly depending on numerous factors, including the number of implants needed, whether bone grafting is required, and the region where you live. However, considering their longevity and the minimal ongoing dental implant maintenance costs, many people find that dental implants offer good value for money over the long term.

Cost of Dentures

The cost of partial dentures start from $1,000. Dentures are generally less expensive upfront than dental implants. However, on average, they require replacement every 5-7 years, which can add to the overall cost. Additionally, there may be costs associated with denture adhesives, denture cleansers, and repairs.

It’s important to note that dental implants and dentures can often be covered, at least in part, by dental health funds. It’s recommended to check with your provider to understand what is covered under your plan.

While cost is an important benefit of dentures, it’s also crucial to consider other aspects such as comfort, aesthetics, and impact on your lifestyle and oral health when choosing between dental implants and dentures.

Suitability: Who Should Choose Dental Implants and Who Should Choose Dentures?

The choice between dental implants and dentures isn’t one-size-fits-all. It depends on personal circumstances, oral health status, jaw bone quality, lifestyle, and preferences. Here are some factors that might make a person a better candidate for one or the other:

Dental Implants

Dental implants might be a good choice for patients who:

  1. Have one or more missing teeth,
  2. Your jaw must have a strong bone that’s reached maturity,
  3. Have a sufficient bone to secure the implants or can have a bone graft,
  4. Have healthy oral tissues,
  5. Don’t have health conditions, such as diabetes and cancer, that will affect bone healing,
  6. Are unable or unwilling to wear dentures,
  7. Want to improve their speech,
  8. Are willing to commit several months to the process and have regular checkups.



Dentures

Dentures might be a good choice for people who:

  1. Have lost all or most of their teeth,
  2. Have significant bone loss that makes dental implants impossible without bone grafting,
  3. Want a more affordable option for tooth loss,
  4. Prefer a non-surgical treatment,
  5. And need a quicker treatment for tooth loss.


It’s important to thoroughly discuss these factors with your dental professional to determine the option for your specific needs and circumstances.

Maintenance and Care: Dental Implants vs Dentures

The daily maintenance and care required for dental implants and dentures differ, and understanding these differences can help you make an informed decision on dentures and dental implants.

Dental Implants

Tooth implants act like natural teeth and require similar care, including:

  1. Regular Brushing and Flossing:
    Dental implants should be brushed twice daily and flossed so that there are no traces of food stuck in teeth gaps, avoiding bacteria and plaque buildup.

  2. Regular Dental Check-ups:
    Regular visits to the dental clinic are important for the implants to function properly and get professional cleanings.

  3. Avoiding Hard Foods:
    While dental implants are durable, biting on hard foods like ice or hard candy can damage the crown.



Dentures

Dentures require a bit more special maintenance, including:

  1. Daily Cleaning:
    Dentures should be removed and cleaned daily with a soft denture brush and non-abrasive denture cleaner, not regular toothpaste.

  2. Soaking Overnight:
    Dentures should be soaked overnight in a cleaning solution to keep them moist and maintain their shape.

  3. Handling with Care:
    Dentures are delicate, so they should be handled carefully.

  4. Regular Dental Check-ups:
    Regular visits to the dental clinic are necessary for the dentures to fit properly and to receive professional cleanings.


By understanding the dental implant maintenance and dental hygiene care requirements of dental implants vs dentures, you can choose the option that fits your lifestyle and personal preferences.

Impact on Lifestyle: Dental Implants vs Dentures

Choosing between dental implants and dentures can significantly impact your lifestyle, affecting everything from eating to speaking to self-confidence. Here’s how:

Dental Implants:

  1. Eating:
    Dental implants act like natural teeth, allowing you to eat various foods without discomfort.

  2. Speaking:
    Because dental implants are securely anchored in your jawbone, they won’t slip or click when you talk, making speech more natural and easier.

  3. Comfort:
    Dental implants feel and function like real teeth, providing comfort close to what you would experience with your natural teeth.

  4. Self-confidence:
    Dental implants look like natural teeth, enhancing overall quality of life and boosting self-confidence.


Dentures:

  1. Eating:
    There may be restrictions on a variety of food you can eat with dentures, especially hard, sticky and chewy foods.

  2. Speaking:
    Dentures can sometimes slip or click when you talk, affecting your speech and requiring adjustment.

  3. Comfort:
    While modern dentures are more comfortable than ever, they may still feel foreign in your mouth, and you may need to use adhesives to keep them in place.

  4. Self-confidence:
    While dentures can significantly improve the appearance of your smile, they may not feel as natural as dental implants, which can affect your self-confidence.


In the end, the choice between dental implants and dentures is a personal one. It’s important to consider all aspects, including how they will impact your lifestyle, and discuss these with your dental professional to decide your needs.

Final Thoughts

Choosing between dental implant treatment and dentures is difficult and can sginificantly impact the quality of your daily life. Both options have pros and cons, depending on your circumstances, oral health, lifestyle, and personal preferences.

Remember, dental implants offer a natural look and feel, longevity, and the ability to maintain bone health. On the other hand, dentures can be a more affordable alternative to implants. They are non-invasive and quicker to fit, making them a suitable choice for many people.

At Dental at Niddrie, we understand that every patient is unique. Our experienced team is dedicated to providing personalised advice and treatment options that meet your needs. We’re here to guide you through the entire process, from initial consultation to aftercare.

If you’re considering dental implants or dentures as an effective tooth replacement option, we invite you to book an appointment. Our dental clinic will be more than happy to discuss your options, answer any questions about dentures or dental implants, and help you make an informed decision about your oral health.

Remember, your smile invests in your confidence, health, and well-being. We will guide you to make the choice between dentures and implants today!

cta footer appointment image

Ready To Schedule An Appointment With Us?

Please book an appointment with us on our website or give our friendly team a call today!

cta footer call us image

Call Us Now!

Our line is open to answer your questions or assist you in arranging your dental appointments. Call us at (03) 9374 1222!

Ready To Schedule An Appointment With Us?

Please book an appointment with us on our website or give our friendly team a call today!

Call Us Now!

Our line is open to answer your questions or assist you in arranging your dental appointments. Call us at (03) 9374 1222!

AREAS WE SERVE

Copyright © 2025 Dental @ Niddrie Plaza

Privacy Policy

Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

Digital Marketing by King Kong

Popular SearchesHide Popular Searches
Book An Appointment